Mergen Demo Data Journalism 48/60
Skip to content
16 November 2026, Monday
AnalysisEconomy

Is AI taking jobs or transforming them? Field notes from five industries

From call centers to accounting, we spoke with workers and employers in five industries. The picture that emerges looks like neither a doomsday scenario nor a rosy promise.

JMJake MoralesSports & Technology Reporter
9 min21.3B2
Is AI taking jobs or transforming them? Field notes from five industries
Table of contents
  1. A quiet transformation in call centers
  2. New skills, old insecurities
  3. Five recommendations for policymakers
  4. Key takeaways

The rapid arrival of AI tools in the workplace is stirring both curiosity and anxiety among workers. For this analysis, we interviewed forty people working in call centers, accounting, logistics, local media and design, along with twelve employers. The interviews suggest that rather than jobs disappearing wholesale, job descriptions are changing piece by piece. But the burden of this transformation falls on the workers with the least access to training and opportunities to adapt. Labor economist Dr. Owen Carver stresses that the real issue is not the technology itself but how the transition is managed.

A quiet transformation in call centers

The most visible change in call centers is that call summaries and standard replies are now drafted by software. The agents we spoke with say they've been freed from note-taking they used to do hundreds of times a day. The same people add that the burden of checking the software's suggested answers has grown along with their targets. The work hasn't gotten shorter; its intensity has changed. One agent says her head feels more tired at the end of the day than it used to.

On the employers' side, the picture is more cautious. Nine of the twelve employers say they use the software not to cut staff but to handle new customer channels with the same team. Even so, two managers openly admitted that they had stopped hiring. In other words, the decline is happening not through layoffs but through positions that are never opened. That is why, in industry statistics, the impact of the transformation looks smaller than it really is.

A quiet transformation in call centers — Is AI taking jobs or transforming them? Field notes from five industries

The machine didn't take my job, but it made half of it unrecognizable.

Jake Morales

New skills, old insecurities

In accounting and local media, the demand for new skills is clear: workers are expected both to use the tools and to verify what they produce. That may look like a welcome upgrade, but it usually comes without extra training or extra pay. Only eight of our forty interviewees said they had attended training organized by their employer. The rest are trying to learn the new tools on their own in the evenings, from online videos.

Insecurity is felt most by freelance designers and logistics coordinators. A freelance designer says clients now want the drafts done by software and pay only for the final touches. Contract workers have little bargaining power, while in unionized sectors the transition is more predictable because its terms can be negotiated. This difference suggests that job security and transformation can go hand in hand.

Five recommendations for policymakers

The first recommendation to come out of our interviews is that the transition should be transparent. Workers should know in advance which tasks will be automated. The second is that paid training hours should be written into employment contracts. The third is that responsibility for software-generated output should be clearly defined; when a mistake is made, the worker should not pay the price. Almost every worker we spoke with shares this demand. Stories of agents reprimanded because of a faulty software output show why this point matters.

Topic Analysis
Highlights artificial intelligence, workers' rights, investigation
Reading time 9 minutes
Written by Jake Morales

Key takeaways

  • Job descriptions aren't disappearing wholesale; they're changing piece by piece.
  • Only eight of forty workers said they had received training from their employer.
  • Recommendations: a transparent transition, paid training and clear lines of responsibility.

The fourth recommendation is reskilling programs run through public-private partnerships, and the fifth is accessible advisory services for small businesses. According to Dr. Owen Carver, none of these steps aims to slow down the technology. The goal is to keep the cost of the transformation from falling on the weakest link and to make sure its gains reach more people. For employers, too, this approach means a more stable working environment in the long run.

JM
Sports & Technology Reporter

Jake Morales

With field experience ranging from Premier Division stadiums to volleyball arenas, Jake Morales follows cybersecurity and artificial intelligence as well as sports news. He is part of the team that tracks the live news feed on publication days.

2 Comments

Share your thoughts

Your email address will not be published. Respectful, on-topic comments are approved.

Data Desk

Welcome back

Log in to your account; your saved posts and comments are waiting for you.