Menemen for Sunday breakfast: a recipe for settling the onion-or-no-onion debate
Staying neutral in the never-ending onion debate, we tried both versions. Our video recipe shows the secrets to perfectly textured menemen, the Turkish scrambled eggs with tomatoes and peppers.
Table of contents
Does menemen get onions or not? The question has fueled an endless debate at breakfast tables and on social media for years. Rather than taking sides, we made both versions with the same ingredients, in two pans side by side. Our video recipe shows step by step how to choose ripe tomatoes and long green peppers, how long to soften the peppers, how to cook the tomatoes down and exactly when the eggs should go into the pan. We found that the onion version comes out sweeter and softer, while the onion-free version is fresher and more tomato-forward. Whichever you choose, the secret to a good menemen is in-season tomatoes and a fire that's never rushed.
Choosing tomatoes and peppers
The foundation of a good menemen is ripe, juicy tomatoes. Since field tomatoes are scarce in November, choose the reddest, most fragrant greenhouse tomatoes you can find. Peeling the tomatoes gives the menemen a smoother texture; just score the bottom of each tomato and dip it in boiling water for a few seconds. Grating or dicing the tomatoes is entirely up to you: grated tomatoes make a looser menemen, while diced tomatoes give it more texture.
For peppers, thin-skinned long green peppers or Charleston peppers are the usual choice. If you like heat, add a hot pepper or two. Slice the peppers into thin rings and remove the seeds if you prefer. We used the same ingredients for both pans: four ripe tomatoes, three long green peppers, four eggs, two tablespoons of olive oil, salt and red pepper flakes. For the onion pan, we also added one medium onion. Using identical ingredients let us compare the two methods fairly.

The onion in menemen is up for debate; the ripeness of its tomatoes never is.
Emily Carter
Two methods, one pan
For the onion version, we sautéed finely chopped onion in olive oil for a few minutes until it turned translucent and lightly golden, then added the peppers and let them soften. For the onion-free version, we put the peppers straight into the olive oil and cooked them until soft. In both pans, once the peppers had softened, we added the grated or diced tomatoes and cooked them over medium heat until their juices had reduced. Cooking took about ten minutes in each pan; the onion pan stayed on the heat a few minutes longer because of the onions. Don't rush the tomatoes as they cook down.
The result was what we expected: the menemen with onion was sweeter, softer and a little richer. The onion-free menemen tasted fresher, lighter and more tomato-forward. Our team's votes were split down the middle, so we decided not to take sides. Which one you choose is entirely down to the tastes at your table. During the tasting, some of our team said the onion version paired better with bread, while others felt the onion-free version made for a lighter breakfast.
The right moment for the eggs
The most critical moment in making menemen is when the eggs go into the pan. Once the tomatoes have reduced and thickened, crack the eggs directly into the pan. Rather than mixing them completely, stirring a few times with a fork so the yolks and whites stay slightly separate gives the menemen a better texture. Turn off the heat before the eggs are fully cooked; the heat of the pan will finish the job. Some home cooks whisk the eggs in a bowl first and then add them to the pan, which gives a more uniform but less textured result.
| Topic | Recipes |
|---|---|
| Highlights | breakfast, recipe, olive oil |
| Reading time | 5 minutes |
| Written by | Emily Carter |
Key takeaways
- Ripe, juicy tomatoes are the foundation of a good menemen.
- The onion version is sweeter; the onion-free version tastes fresher.
- Turn off the heat before the eggs are fully cooked.
Overcooked eggs make menemen dry and rubbery. Add the salt and red pepper flakes at the very end. Serve the menemen hot, straight from the pan, with fresh bread and a glass of tea. If you like, top it with a little crumbled white cheese or grated mild cheese. You can watch both versions being made step by step in our video recipe. Serving menemen hot matters, because as it cools the texture of the eggs changes and it loses its flavor.
What do you think about this post?


































































Leave a comment