Mergen Demo Investigative 13/60
Skip to content
Genel

Special report: The social housing queue, stories of families on the waiting list

We met families who have waited years for affordable housing. Our report shows what the right to shelter looks like from the waiting room.

ECEmily CarterManaging Editor
11 min9.6B0
Table of contents
  1. Lottery day: Hope and disappointment
  2. Who should get priority?
  3. What are other countries doing?
  4. Key takeaways

As names are read out one by one in the lottery hall, hundreds of families hold their breath. Because applicants for affordable housing far outnumber the homes on offer, most families wait years for their turn. Most of the families we spoke with say they spend more than half their income on rent. Urban planner Dr. Simon Avery says priority criteria and project locations need to be rethought around the people in need. In our video report, we also compare social housing models from different countries.

Lottery day: Hope and disappointment

Families start filing into the lottery hall early in the morning and line up with folders of paperwork in hand. Most are not taking part in the draw for the first time. One mother says she has come to every lottery for three years and her children are tired of waiting for the next one. When the names start being read out, the hall falls so silent you can hear paper rustling. Those whose names aren't called quietly leave the hall.

For the winners, the joy is often short-lived. New questions arise: the months until the home is handed over, the down payment and monthly installments, the cost of moving. One father says he cried when his name was read out, then sat silent for hours the next day looking at the payment schedule. Affordable housing isn't equally affordable for everyone on a modest income.

Lottery day: Hope and disappointment — Special report: The social housing queue, stories of families on the waiting list

At every lottery, I tell my kids that this time it'll be us.

Emily Carter

Who should get priority?

Priority criteria are at the heart of the waiting list debate. The order in which poor households, large families, people with disabilities and young couples are considered varies from project to project. Planners we spoke with say publishing the scoring system transparently, where everyone can see it, is the first condition for trust. Even getting the keys to the new home can take months. In the meantime, many families keep renting and dealing with rent hikes.

Location is another important factor. Many social housing projects are far from the city center, in areas with limited public transit. Families who get a home can spend two or three hours a day commuting to work. Dr. Simon Avery says location should be thought of as part of income, and that a cheap home far away often stops being cheap once transportation costs are added.

What are other countries doing?

In our video, we compare the social housing models of three countries. In one, housing cooperatives work with long-term, low-interest loans, and a board oversees rent increases. In another, municipalities require private developers to set aside a share of affordable homes in every new project. In the third, public renting is widespread and owning a home isn't necessary.

Topic Special Report
Highlights housing crisis, urban renewal, investigation
Reading time 11 minutes
Written by Emily Carter

Key takeaways

  • Applications far outnumber the homes on offer, and families wait for years.
  • Remote locations can make cheap housing expensive because of commuting costs.
  • The report compares the social housing models of three countries.

No model is perfect. Each has its problems, such as queues, waiting times and local resistance. But what they share is that housing is treated as a public service and planned for the long term. According to Avery, the first step in our own debate is to talk about who the homes are for, where they'll be built and on what terms, before talking about how many to build.

Share this post
EC
Managing Editor

Emily Carter

Emily Carter runs the Agenda24 news desk, holding politics and crime coverage to strict standards of verification and plain writing. After fifteen years in the national press, she now plans the editorial team's daily output.

Leave a comment

Share your thoughts

Your email address will not be published. Respectful, on-topic comments are approved.

News Central

Welcome back

Log in to your account; your saved posts and comments are waiting for you.