Mergen Demo Investigative 13/60
Skip to content
Rent or salary? We calculated young people's housing burden over the past decade
DataEconomy

Rent or salary? We calculated young people’s housing burden over the past decade

Using ten years of data, we calculated how much of a recent graduate's salary goes to rent. The result explains why young people are leaving home later.

MEMark EllisonEconomy & Technology Reporter
9 min19.6B0
Table of contents
  1. How we did the math
  2. Rent as a share of salary
  3. The generation that can't leave home
  4. Key takeaways

For a recent graduate, renting a first home was once the natural step toward independence. In this study, we compared ten years of listings data with entry-level wages to calculate young people's housing burden. In major cities, the rent on a studio apartment rose markedly as a share of a graduate's salary over the period. Most of the young people we spoke with see living with roommates or staying with their parents as a necessity. Sociologist Dr. Eva Billings stresses that this also directly affects decisions about marriage, having children and careers.

How we did the math

We began the calculation with ten years of listings data. We compiled the average monthly rent for studio apartment listings in major cities year by year. We then compared these with entry-level wages published over the same period. We used net pay, because the money a young person actually takes home is very different from the gross figure. For wage data, we drew on records from professional associations and job portals.

We also want to put the weaknesses of our method on record. The asking price in a listing is not always the rent actually paid; room for negotiation and furnished apartments account for the difference. On the wage side, the gap between sectors is large. So instead of a single number, we present a low and a high range. Whichever end of the range you take, the trend points the same way.

How we did the math — Rent or salary? We calculated young people's housing burden over the past decade

I'm thirty and I still sleep in my childhood bedroom.

Mark Ellison

Rent as a share of salary

Ten years ago, about a third of a recent graduate's salary went to rent on a studio apartment. Today, in most major cities, that share is approaching half, and in some areas it exceeds it. The numbers leave very little for other items such as social life, transportation and food. Saving anything from what's left after rent is almost impossible.

The regional gap is also large. The burden is heaviest in the three biggest metropolitan areas, while the share is lower in mid-sized cities. But because job options in those cities are limited, young people still head for the big cities. That drives up demand and pushes rents higher. So the problem isn't just rent; it's that jobs and affordable housing aren't in the same place.

The generation that can't leave home

The next effect the data reveal is that the age at which young people start living on their own is rising. Most of the young people we spoke with describe living with roommates or staying with their parents not as a choice but as a necessity. Many dreamed of becoming independent when they got their first paycheck, but did the math three months later and moved back home. Young people stress that these delays are not their choice but a necessity imposed by circumstance.

Topic Data
Highlights housing crisis, youth, data journalism
Reading time 9 minutes
Written by Mark Ellison

Key takeaways

  • Over ten years, studio rents rose markedly as a share of a graduate's salary.
  • In big cities, rent can approach half of a person's take-home pay.
  • Rising housing costs make roommates or living with parents a necessity, not a choice.

According to sociologist Dr. Eva Billings, this generation has given up on owning a home and can't even see renting as a long-term plan. Decisions about marriage, having children and career advancement are being put off accordingly. Policy proposals include rental assistance for young tenants, social rental housing and more low-cost dormitory places, but none of them looks sufficient on its own.

Share this post
ME
Economy & Technology Reporter

Mark Ellison

Mark Ellison covers markets, household finances and new technology, and is known for in-depth reports that connect complex data to readers' everyday lives. He previously worked on the economics desks of two major news agencies.

Leave a comment

Share your thoughts

Your email address will not be published. Respectful, on-topic comments are approved.

News Central

Welcome back

Log in to your account; your saved posts and comments are waiting for you.