Mergen Demo Investigative 13/60
Skip to content
The data speak: The regional gap in school achievement is widening
DataSociety

The data speak: The regional gap in school achievement is widening

We analyzed five years of exam results by region and district. The findings show that students' achievement varies dramatically depending on where they live.

MEMark EllisonEconomy & Technology Reporter
10 min15.7B0
Table of contents
  1. Our method of analysis
  2. Inequality on the map
  3. The factors that make the difference
  4. Key takeaways

How much of a child's success in school depends on talent and effort, and how much on where they were born? To answer that question, we analyzed five years of national exam results alongside district-level socioeconomic indicators and school infrastructure data. The picture is striking: far from closing, the gap between the best- and worst-performing districts has kept widening over the past five years. Teacher turnover is one of the leading factors.

Our method of analysis

We began the analysis by compiling five years of exam results at the regional and district level. We matched the results with each district's socioeconomic indicators, students per teacher and the condition of school buildings. This gave us an achievement score for each district and a set of variables that try to explain it. We share every step openly.

To keep the comparison fair, we also took students' family circumstances into account. By comparing districts with the same income levels, we tried to separate the effect of school conditions from that of poverty alone. Our method has limits: exam scores are not the only measure of education, and a district average doesn't represent every child in it. Still, the trend was consistent.

Our method of analysis — The data speak: The regional gap in school achievement is widening

A zip code should not decide a child's future.

Mark Ellison

Inequality on the map

On the map, inequality follows a center-periphery divide more than any east-west line. In some regions, the gap between a big city's central districts and the outlying districts of the same region is even larger than the gap between regions. A gap that was close to closing five years ago is widening again. Unequal access to remote learning after the pandemic in particular seems to have deepened the wounds. Even within the same regional borders, the difference in achievement between districts is plain to see.

At one end of the map are districts where high-scoring students mostly have access to private tutoring centers or one-on-one help at home. At the other are areas where single-teacher village schools, combined classes and bused-in students are common. In these districts, students set out early in the morning and get home late in the evening, and struggle to find the time and a quiet place to study.

The factors that make the difference

Teacher turnover tops the list of factors explaining the achievement gap. How many years a teacher stays at a school on average turned out to be significantly linked to student achievement. Because most teachers posted to hardship areas leave after a few years, these schools never develop continuity. That makes it harder to follow the curriculum and to build trust with students.

Topic Data
Highlights data journalism, education inequality, youth
Reading time 10 minutes
Written by Mark Ellison

Key takeaways

  • In some regions, the gap between districts is larger than the gap between regions.
  • How long teachers stay at a school was significantly linked to achievement.
  • Access to preschool appears to help narrow the gap.

The second factor is access to preschool. In districts with high kindergarten enrollment, the achievement gap after primary school is smaller. The third is the condition of school buildings and laboratories. Education researchers recommend distributing resources in ways that reduce inequality, strengthening incentives for teachers to stay and expanding early childhood education. What these recommendations have in common is that resources should go first to the schools that need them most.

Share this post
ME
Economy & Technology Reporter

Mark Ellison

Mark Ellison covers markets, household finances and new technology, and is known for in-depth reports that connect complex data to readers' everyday lives. He previously worked on the economics desks of two major news agencies.

Leave a comment

Share your thoughts

Your email address will not be published. Respectful, on-topic comments are approved.

News Central

Welcome back

Log in to your account; your saved posts and comments are waiting for you.