Mergen Demo Darkroom 49/60
Skip to content
Did AI-powered masking really cut my editing time?
Editing

Did AI-powered masking really cut my editing time?

I used AI masking tools, which select the sky, subject and background in seconds, in my workflow for a month.

EBEthan BrooksWorld & Environment Reporter
7 min0

The AI-powered masking tools added to photo editing software have cut selection work that took hours a few years ago down to seconds. Selecting the sky, the subject or the background with a single click sounds great, but how reliable is it in a real workflow? For a month I did all my edits with these tools and noted how much time I spent on each photo. The results showed big gains in some areas, while some frames still needed manual work.

In this article

  • How accurate are automatic masks?
  • Skin and eye retouching in portraits
  • Time saved and trade-offs

How accurate are automatic masks?

The sky mask was the tool with the best results. Even sky showing through tree branches was selected almost perfectly in a few seconds. Brushing in branches one by one, which used to take hours, was done with a single click. The subject mask also gave clean results on most frames, especially in portraits where the background clearly stood apart.

Where it struggled was with strands of hair, sheer fabrics and low-contrast edges. In these cases, slight halos and wrongly selected areas appeared along the mask edge. Over a month and about two hundred photos, the share of frames where I used the automatic mask as is was around 70%. For the remaining 30%, I had to fix the edges by hand.

How accurate are automatic masks? — Did AI-powered masking really cut my editing time?

AI makes the selection, but you still decide what to emphasize.

Ethan Brooks

Skin and eye retouching in portraits

Skin and eye retouching in portraits is the most controversial area of AI. The automatic skin mask selects facial features and eyes separately, allowing quick adjustments. Adding a little brightness and sharpness to the eyes now takes seconds. But over-smoothing the skin easily ruins a portrait's naturalness. That's why I've made a habit of doing a before-and-after comparison after every fine adjustment.

My rule is to keep skin retouching at very low intensity. Reducing shadows under the eyes or removing temporary blemishes is reasonable; changing a person's facial features is not for me. When I share the photo with my subject, I think they should still look like themselves. The tools are fast and powerful, but you still decide where to stop. In this respect the tools are only helpers; the real decision is made by your eye and your conscience.

Time saved and trade-offs

When I measured the time saved, the editing time for an average photo dropped from about four minutes to two and a half. The difference was even greater for landscape frames needing many local adjustments and for group portrait sessions. In total, it saved about sixteen hours a month. The time difference is felt even more after big shoots with lots of frames.

Topic Editing
Highlights editing, RAW, portrait
Reading time 7 minutes
Written by Ethan Brooks

Key takeaways

  • The sky mask is the most accurate tool; hair and sheer fabrics are challenging.
  • Skin retouching in portraits stays natural when kept at low intensity.
  • Average editing time dropped from four minutes to two and a half.

There are trade-offs, too. As speed increases, you tend to pay less attention to each frame and apply masks with too much confidence. And when the tools make small mistakes at the edges, you won't catch them unless you look on a big screen. In the end, AI masking really did cut my editing time, but without a good eye and the habit of checking, the results aren't satisfying.

What do you think about this post?

EB
World & Environment Reporter

Ethan Brooks

Ethan Brooks follows international affairs and climate news, bringing his experience covering summits and reporting from the field to Agenda24's world and environment pages. He has also worked on documentaries about conservation and sustainable cities.

Leave a comment

Share your thoughts

Your email address will not be published. Respectful, on-topic comments are approved.

Darkroom

Welcome back

Log in to your account; your saved posts and comments are waiting for you.