Mergen Demo Music 24/60
Skip to content
Genel

The Comets’ comeback album ‘Old City’: was it worth the ten-year wait?

Back together after a ten-year break, The Comets return with 'Old City', a familiar but matured sound. We reviewed the album track by track.

SBSarah BennettHealth, Education & Lifestyle Editor
7 min0

Formed in the late nineties and one of the most beloved bands on the independent scene in the early 2000s, The Comets are back after a ten-year break with their new album 'Old City'. After the split, each member worked on different projects, and rumors of a reunion were denied for years. The nine-track album keeps the band's signature twin-guitar setup while standing out with slower tempos, calmer vocals and a mature production. We listened to the album track by track and considered what longtime fans and new listeners can expect from it. The short answer is yes, but the long answer is a little more complicated and interesting.

In this article

  • In the same room after ten years
  • 'Old City', track by track
  • For longtime fans and new listeners

In the same room after ten years

The story of the band's reunion began in an unexpected place: at a wedding table. Sitting at the same table for the first time in ten years at an old friend's wedding, the band members got up on stage at the end of the night and played two of their old songs. The next day, the singer suggested trying out a few new songs together. They say that when they walked into the same room on the first day of rehearsals, they played for half an hour without saying a word. That silent rehearsal set the tone of the new album and brought them back together.

The band members openly admit that the years apart are reflected in their sound. One spent the time composing film music, another trained in jazz, and a third stepped away from music entirely for years to open a craft workshop. These different experiences added new layers to the band's signature twin-guitar setup. Unlike the band's old methods, the album was recorded with everyone playing live together, with little editing afterward.

In the same room after ten years — The Comets' comeback album 'Old City': was it worth the ten-year wait?

When we walked into the same room, we played for the first half hour without saying a word.

Sarah Bennett

'Old City', track by track

The album's opening track starts with a fast guitar riff that winks at longtime fans, but it soon slows down to hint at the overall mood of the album. The second and third tracks stand out with strong melodies reminiscent of the band's best years. The long, calm track at the center of the album is perhaps the most mature song of their career. Here the two guitars' call-and-response lines beautifully reflect the shared language the band has developed over the years.

The second half of the album is more uneven. Tracks six and seven contain good ideas but feel a little rushed. The closing track, however, ties the album together powerfully: a slowly building wall of guitars and the singer's voice, more fragile than ever, feel like an emotional payoff for the ten-year wait. The production is warm and natural throughout; the band's choice to record live gives the album an intimate feel and makes it convincing.

For longtime fans and new listeners

For longtime fans, 'Old City' is a much slower, more reflective record than the band's last album before the split. Those expecting fast, loud songs may be disappointed on first listen. But after a few spins, it becomes clear that this is a record showing a band that has matured without losing its character. Small nods to old songs on the album also offer pleasant surprises for those who've followed the band for years, and they'll raise a smile.

Topic Albums
Highlights album review, rock, guitar
Reading time 7 minutes
Written by Sarah Bennett

Key takeaways

  • The Comets are back after ten years with 'Old City'.
  • The album was recorded live, with minimal editing.
  • The band will play a limited number of concerts in spring.

For those hearing the band for the first time, 'Old City' could be a good starting point. The album offers a more accessible sound than their earlier records and appeals to fans of indie rock's calm, melodic side. The band announced that they'll play a limited number of concerts in spring following the album. The countdown to ticket sales has already begun. The shows will feature both the new album and older songs, and excitement is high.

What do you think about this post?

SB
Health, Education & Lifestyle Editor

Sarah Bennett

Writing on public health, schools and everyday life, Sarah Bennett aims to turn expert opinion into advice readers can actually use. She edits Agenda24's health and education pages.

Leave a comment

Share your thoughts

Your email address will not be published. Respectful, on-topic comments are approved.

Frequency

Welcome back

Log in to your account; your saved posts and comments are waiting for you.