Mergen Demo Electric Future 45/60
Skip to content
ComparisonsRoad Tests

Compact SUV comparison: gasoline, hybrid and electric rivals side by side

We tested three compact SUVs from the same segment with different powertrains on the same route on the same day. In our comparison video, we answer which one makes most sense for whom.

SLSophie LaurentArts & Entertainment Editor
6 min14.9B0
Table of contents
  1. Same route, three different characters
  2. Cabin and trunk comparison
  3. Fuel economy and cost table
  4. Key takeaways

The compact SUV segment is one of the most popular car classes on the market. But with gasoline, hybrid and electric options multiplying within the same segment, deciding is harder than ever. In this comparison we tested three rivals with three different technologies on the same day, on the same route and with the same drivers. Besides the consumption figures we measured in the city, on the highway and on winding roads, we also scored cabin comfort, trunk usability and the infotainment systems. Our results and recommendations are in the comparison video.

Same route, three different characters

All three cars in the comparison were compact SUVs of similar size and in a similar price range. One was a turbocharged gasoline model, one a full hybrid and the third fully electric. Our route was roughly 180 km (112 miles): 20 km in the city, 100 km on the highway and 60 km on winding roads. The same drivers took turns in each car.

With its strong acceleration and familiar driving feel, the gasoline car felt the most natural at first. The hybrid stood out in town with its quietness and low consumption. The electric car made a difference with its instant torque and silent cabin. In corners, the electric car, with its low center of gravity, felt the most composed. These differences in character became even clearer in the consumption and cost section.

Same route, three different characters — Compact SUV comparison: gasoline, hybrid and electric rivals side by side

The real winner of a comparison isn't a car, but the driver who decides with the right information.

Sophie Laurent

Cabin and trunk comparison

In terms of cabin space, all three cars could comfortably carry four adults. The electric car's flat floor was a clear advantage for the rear middle passenger. In the gasoline car, the rear seats were mounted slightly higher. The hybrid's battery placement creates a slight rise in the trunk floor. This layout makes a big difference on long trips and keeps passengers happier.

Trunk volumes are close: the gasoline car offers the most space, while the electric car can set aside a separate spot for the charging cable thanks to its front trunk. In infotainment, the electric car had the smoothest software; the gasoline car's menus were a little more complicated. In the hybrid, physical buttons made things easier to use. For tech-savvy users, that difference may matter.

Fuel economy and cost table

The consumption figures we measured on the same route painted different pictures. The gasoline car used around 7.4 liters per 100 km (32 mpg), the hybrid 4.9 liters (48 mpg) and the electric car 17.5 kWh. At current fuel and electricity prices, the cost per 100 km ranked electric first, then hybrid, then gasoline. These figures are reliable because they are comparable values obtained on the same route with the same drivers.

Topic Comparisons
Highlights comparison, SUV, hybrid
Reading time 6 minutes
Written by Sophie Laurent

Key takeaways

  • We compared gasoline, hybrid and electric SUVs on the same route with the same drivers.
  • On running costs it's electric, hybrid, gasoline; on purchase price it's the reverse.
  • Above 30,000 km a year, the electric car pulls ahead on total cost.

The purchase price, however, reverses the order. The gasoline car is the cheapest and the electric car the most expensive. Once annual mileage exceeds 30,000 km (18,600 miles), the electric car pulls ahead on total cost. For short distances, gasoline and hybrid remain more advantageous. Those with access to charging who want a quiet drive may settle on the electric car, while those who can't charge may opt for the hybrid.

Share this post

What do you think about this post?

SL
Arts & Entertainment Editor

Sophie Laurent

A former film, music and performing arts reporter, Sophie Laurent covers festivals and exhibitions alongside the colorful world of entertainment news. In her interviews, she likes to put the story the artist is telling front and center, rather than the artist.

Leave a comment

Share your thoughts

Your email address will not be published. Respectful, on-topic comments are approved.

Voltage

Welcome back

Log in to your account; your saved posts and comments are waiting for you.