Mergen Demo Living 12/60
Skip to content
Job interviews in the creative industry: common mistakes in portfolio presentations
CareerDesign

Job interviews in the creative industry: common mistakes in portfolio presentations

A strong portfolio can be overshadowed by a weak presentation. We asked creative directors about the mistakes they see most often in interviews and how to avoid them.

EBEthan BrooksWorld & Environment Reporter
7 min10.2B0
Table of contents
  1. Trying to show everything
  2. Not explaining the process
  3. Arriving unprepared for questions
  4. Key takeaways

In a creative job interview, how you present your portfolio matters as much as the portfolio itself. The creative directors we spoke to say the most common mistake candidates make is rushing through every project with equal weight. A good presentation should instead clearly convey the story of a few selected projects, the problems faced and the decisions made. With advice from creative director Tom Sexton, we've gathered ways to stand out at the interview table.

Trying to show everything

Trying to show everything is the mistake creative directors see most often. Tom Sexton says candidates who show twenty projects in an interview skip through most of them in ten seconds, and by the end he doesn't remember any of them. Walking through three or four projects in depth leaves a much stronger impression. Decide which projects to choose based on the position you're applying for.

When choosing, he suggests asking: Does this work show how I think? It makes sense to cut work that looks good but has no story behind it. Prepare a roughly five-minute narrative for each project and leave room for the interviewer's questions. Timing your presentation in advance and rehearsing in front of a friend are the most practical ways to keep nerves in check.

Trying to show everything — Job interviews in the creative industry: common mistakes in portfolio presentations

What you say in an interview matters as much as what you show.

Ethan Brooks

Not explaining the process

Not explaining the process is the second big mistake. Sexton says candidates show the final image and move straight on to the next project, when what really interests the interviewer is how the process worked. What the problem was, what research was done, which alternatives were tried and why this solution was chosen reveal how a designer thinks.

When explaining your process, you don't have to make everything look flawless. Sexton finds it especially valuable when candidates share a mistake they made on a project and the lesson they took from it. It shows maturity and a willingness to learn. When describing teamwork, it's also important to draw a clear line between “we” and “I,” stating your own contribution clearly without exaggerating it.

Arriving unprepared for questions

Arriving unprepared for questions is another thing that weakens a good portfolio. Sexton lists questions that come up often in interviews: Why this company? Which piece of work are you proudest of? How did you resolve a difficult situation with a client? Writing out answers to these in advance helps you speak more comfortably in the moment. Rather than memorizing the answers, boiling the main ideas down to three-word notes helps you find a natural flow.

Topic Career
Highlights career, portfolio, freelancing
Reading time 7 minutes
Written by Ethan Brooks

Key takeaways

  • Covering three or four projects in depth beats skimming through twenty.
  • The problem, alternatives and decisions are what show the process.
  • Preparing for common questions in advance makes the interview easier.

Asking the interviewer questions is part of the preparation too. Asking how the team works, how projects are evaluated and what's expected of you in the first three months shows genuine interest. Finally, Sexton suggests sending a short thank-you message after the interview. An interview isn't an exam but a conversation in which both sides get to know each other; candidates who prepare with that mindset are usually more at ease.

Share this post

What do you think about this post?

EB
World & Environment Reporter

Ethan Brooks

Ethan Brooks follows international affairs and climate news, bringing his experience covering summits and reporting from the field to Agenda24's world and environment pages. He has also worked on documentaries about conservation and sustainable cities.

Leave a comment

Share your thoughts

Your email address will not be published. Respectful, on-topic comments are approved.

Studio Notes

Welcome back

Log in to your account; your saved posts and comments are waiting for you.