Analysis: Where is the housing market heading in an era of high rates?
Persistently high borrowing costs are shifting the balance between new and resale home sales. Experts point to the long-term effects of shrinking supply.

With tight monetary policy still in place, the housing market looks unusual. As mortgage rates remain high, the share of mortgage-financed sales in the total is falling, while investors able to buy in cash have become more influential. Real estate economist Victor Hayes notes that rising construction costs have slowed new project starts, which could lead to a supply shortage in the medium term. According to Hayes, the start of a rate-cutting cycle could bring pent-up demand rushing back into the market. In our analysis, we look at different scenarios.
In this article
- A drop in mortgage-financed sales
- Construction costs and supply
- Scenarios for the period ahead
A drop in mortgage-financed sales
Mortgage-financed home sales have fallen markedly during the period of high interest rates. For many buyers, the ratio of monthly payments to household income has become an insurmountable threshold. Cash sales and investment purchases, by contrast, have increased their share of the market. The shift affects the mix of sales more than their total number. The picture shows the housing market being reshaped structurally.
The balance between new and resale homes is also changing. Developers are trying to reach buyers with promotions, long-term payment plans and direct financing models, while room for price negotiation has widened in the resale market. Real estate agents say sellers are resisting lowering their price expectations, which is lengthening the time it takes to sell. In both segments, the gap between buyers' and sellers' price expectations remains wide.

Housing demand put on hold today could become the market's biggest driver tomorrow.
Mark Ellison
Construction costs and supply
On the supply side, costs are decisive. Prices for building materials, labor and land are rising, while developers' access to financing has become harder. According to Victor Hayes, these conditions are slowing new project starts and putting particular pressure on small and medium-sized contractors. The slowdown in housing construction could lead to a supply shortage in the medium term. This lengthens projects' payback periods, making investors more cautious.
Social housing and urban regeneration projects by public agencies are among the factors supporting the supply balance. However, the timing and regional distribution of these projects may not be enough to close the supply gap in the big cities, where need is greatest. Experts say speeding up zoning procedures and increasing the supply of buildable land would be a lasting solution for price balance. The pace of regeneration projects depends on the capacity of the municipalities involved.
Scenarios for the period ahead
Three different scenarios stand out for the period ahead. In the first, rates stay high for a long time, sales remain low and prices fall in real terms. In the second, rate cuts begin gradually and the market sees a slow recovery. In the third, a rapid drop in rates causes pent-up demand to return to the market all at once.
| Topic | Analysis |
|---|---|
| Highlights | central bank, investment, rent |
| Reading time | 8 minutes |
| Written by | Mark Ellison |
Key takeaways
- High rates have pushed down mortgage-financed sales, while the share of cash purchases has risen.
- Construction costs are slowing new project starts, raising the risk of a supply squeeze.
- The start of rate cuts could quickly bring pent-up demand back to the market.
According to Hayes, the most likely outlook is something close to the second scenario. However, because pent-up demand is strong, sales could recover quickly once rate cuts begin. In that case, the supply shortage would become more pronounced and prices would come under pressure again. Experts advise buyers to plan their budgets carefully and avoid taking on debt beyond their ability to pay.



































































Leave a comment