Mergen Demo Law Firm 26/60
Skip to content
Employment & Business

Shareholders’ agreements in private companies: which clauses matter?

When a company is founded, harmony among shareholders often rests on verbal trust. In times of growth and change, written arrangements protect that trust.

SLSophie LaurentArts & Entertainment Editor
6 min2
Shareholders' agreements in private companies: which clauses matter?
Table of contents
  1. Articles of association vs. shareholders' agreement
  2. Key clauses
  3. If a dispute arises
  4. Key takeaways

Private limited companies are one of the most popular business structures. The articles of association drafted at formation set out essentials such as the company's name, capital and management. Many aspects of the relationship between shareholders, however, are not covered there, or are things shareholders would rather not see on the public register. A shareholders' agreement fills this gap and sets the rules among the shareholders themselves. In this article, we summarize the topics we recommend including in a shareholders' agreement.

Articles of association vs. shareholders' agreement

The articles of association are filed with the companies registry and are open to public inspection. They must comply with the mandatory provisions of company law, and amending them requires a shareholder resolution and registration. A shareholders' agreement, on the other hand, is a binding contract between the parties; it binds the shareholders rather than the company and can be kept confidential.

It is important that the two documents do not conflict. For example, if the articles allow shares to be transferred freely while the shareholders' agreement provides for pre-emption rights, problems can arise in practice. For this reason, it is worth considering whether some of the matters covered in the shareholders' agreement should also be reflected in the articles.

Articles of association vs. shareholders' agreement — Shareholders' agreements in private companies: which clauses matter?

A partnership prepares for hard times with rules written down in good times.

Sophie Laurent

Key clauses

A shareholders' agreement can cover capital commitments and what happens if more capital is needed, the appointment and powers of managers, the majorities required for key decisions, dividend policy and non-compete obligations for shareholders. For startups taking on investment in particular, the investor's rights and information rights should be set out in detail.

Clauses on share transfers such as pre-emption rights, tag-along rights and drag-along rights provide guidance if a shareholder leaves or the company is sold. How shares will be valued if a shareholder dies, wants to leave or breaches the agreement can also be agreed in advance.

If a dispute arises

When a dispute arises between shareholders, the dispute resolution method set out in the shareholders' agreement becomes important. The parties may agree on mediation, arbitration or the jurisdiction of a particular court. For commercial disputes over a sum of money, applying to a mediator before filing suit is required by law.

Topic Employment & Business
Highlights company formation, mediation
Reading time 6 minutes
Written by Sophie Laurent

Key takeaways

  • A shareholders' agreement binds the shareholders and can be kept confidential; the articles appear on the public register.
  • Share transfers, voting majorities and exit terms should be set out in writing in advance.
  • Agreeing on a method for resolving deadlock is recommended.

It is also useful to agree in advance on a method for deadlock — situations where the shareholders cannot reach a decision on an important matter. Referring the issue to an independent expert, an obligation to negotiate for a set period or buy-sell mechanisms can all serve this purpose. These arrangements help prevent the company's day-to-day operations from grinding to a halt because of a dispute.

Share this post
SL
Arts & Entertainment Editor

Sophie Laurent

A former film, music and performing arts reporter, Sophie Laurent covers festivals and exhibitions alongside the colorful world of entertainment news. In her interviews, she likes to put the story the artist is telling front and center, rather than the artist.

2 Comments

Share your thoughts

Your email address will not be published. Respectful, on-topic comments are approved.

Sterling & Hale Law Partners

Welcome back

Log in to your account; your saved posts and comments are waiting for you.