Mergen Demo Gadget Lab 38/60
Skip to content
Noise-canceling headphones compared: Five models, one winner
Wearables

Noise-canceling headphones compared: Five models, one winner

We compared five popular over-ear and in-ear noise-canceling headphones on sound quality, comfort, battery life and noise cancellation performance.

MEMark EllisonEconomy & Technology Reporter
10 min13.5B0
Table of contents
  1. Noise cancellation tests
  2. Sound quality and comfort
  3. Which one is right for whom?
  4. Key takeaways

For peaceful listening on public transport, in open-plan offices or on flights, active noise cancellation has become a necessity. So we tested the five most popular headphones on the market under the same conditions. We measured noise cancellation using subway car, café and airplane cabin sounds, and assessed their sound signatures with different music genres. Comfort over long listening sessions and real-world battery life were also key factors in our comparison.

Noise cancellation tests

We measured the five headphones in three settings that mimic real life: a subway car, a busy café and an airplane cabin. We played the recordings through speakers at realistic levels and measured how much of that sound each pair blocked with a microphone placed inside an artificial ear. We repeated the same test three times for each model. The ambient recordings were taken from real travel sounds.

For low-frequency rumble, such as airplane engines and subway wheels, the over-ear models performed better. All of the headphones struggled with mid frequencies like human voices. Thanks to its choice of ear tips, one of the in-ear models delivered isolation close to the over-ears. Microphone performance in wind noise also varied. These results show that headphones that excel in one setting may not be great everywhere.

Noise cancellation tests — Noise-canceling headphones compared: Five models, one winner

Good noise cancellation is like a door that shuts out the sound of the city.

Mark Ellison

Sound quality and comfort

Sound signature and comfort make the difference over long listening sessions. Two over-ear models had a balanced, natural sound profile, bringing vocals forward while keeping the bass in check. Another offers more pronounced bass, appealing to electronic music fans. Despite their small size, the in-ear models delivered surprising detail. The difference becomes clear over long listening sessions.

In the comfort test, after a three-hour session one of the over-ear models pressed on the top of the head, while the other stayed comfortable even on hot summer days thanks to its breathable cushions. With in-ear models, trying different tip sizes is a must. Call quality mattered too: in windy conditions, only two models transmitted our voice clearly.

Which one is right for whom?

Battery life fell short of the figures on the box. With noise cancellation on, the over-ear models lasted between 25 and 32 hours; the in-ear models reached a total of 20 hours including the case. A ten-minute quick charge is enough for three to four hours of listening on most models. We also checked the accuracy of the battery indicators and found the deviations were small.

Topic Wearables
Highlights headphones, comparison, battery life
Reading time 10 minutes
Written by Mark Ellison

Key takeaways

  • All five models were measured the same way in subway, café and airplane settings.
  • Over-ears lead at low frequencies; cushion design decides comfort.
  • Real-world battery life came in slightly below the advertised figures.

We picked the winner based on the balance of sound, noise cancellation and comfort scores. For frequent flyers we recommend the top over-ear model, and for people who work out, the second in-ear model. If you're on a budget, the mid-priced model was surprisingly good at noise cancellation. Whichever you choose, we recommend trying it before you buy if you can. Asking about the return policy before buying keeps you from getting stuck with headphones that don't suit you.

Share this post

What do you think about this post?

ME
Economy & Technology Reporter

Mark Ellison

Mark Ellison covers markets, household finances and new technology, and is known for in-depth reports that connect complex data to readers' everyday lives. He previously worked on the economics desks of two major news agencies.

Leave a comment

Share your thoughts

Your email address will not be published. Respectful, on-topic comments are approved.

Gadget House

Welcome back

Log in to your account; your saved posts and comments are waiting for you.